Back to starting status. Got a starter from AZ this time, but its the same exact unit as the Carquest. Looking on RA, they all appear to be the same unit. No options for name brand.
I think it's been broken for a while. I've been chalking the extra noise up to cold start and low battery. It all makes sense now. After the car was warm, it didn't make any excessive noise. Flywheel has some chips, but nothing major.
Found the hub centric rings that I though I had for the winter wheels, laying in my back yard
.